Takeaways from Buffalo’s loss to Kansas City


It’s back to the drawing board for the Buffalo Bills.

After a 4-0 start fueled by a high-powered offense, the Bills have now dropped back-to-back games before a prime-time audience. Buffalo looked anything but the heir-apparent to the New England Patriots in the AFC East.

Hosting Kansas City Monday night at Bills Stadium, the Bills dropped a 26-17 final in a contest that was not nearly as close as the final score indicates.

The Chiefs turned to their ground game, and punctured the Buffalo defense to the tune of 245 rushing yards.

Bills head coach, Sean McDermott, after Monday’s loss:  “We’ve got to look at our football team, and be truthful with ourselves, and say what do we have  to get corrected.”

What needs correction? Read the five takeaways after Monday’s game:

Allen regressed

For much of Monday’s game, Allen was under the 50 percent completion mark, and he missed open receivers a la his rookie season. There may have been a bad read or two, but it looked like Allen’s mechanics were off. His misfires – including his late-game interception – he was backing up, throwing off his back foot, or was a half-second late releasing the ball.

Some quarterbacks are just gifted at throwing the ball from any position (Aaron Rodgers and Patrick Mahomes to name two). Allen is not one of those guys. Allen has a missile for an arm, and when his footwork is good, he can squeeze the ball into any tight window.  That said, when the footwork is off, Allen’s accuracy is akin to a backup JV quarterback.

Singletary is not a franchise running back

The second-year product has elusiveness and some initial quickness at the point of attack, but he’s a step slower than your prototypical tailback.

The metrics do not lie. Singletary’s 40-yard time in last year’s combine was 4.66 seconds. As a comparison, the Titans’ Derrick Henry – who is eight inches taller and 40 pounds heavier than Singletary – ran a 4.54 40-yard time in his combine.

Rookie running back Zack Moss isn’t much better. Singletary’s backup, ran a 4.65 40 in his combine, which was the fourth slowest out of 28 backs at this year’s NFL combine.

Singletary is good at making the first person miss, but he lacks the burst or explosion that yields chunk runs.

Based on his 40 times at his Alabama pro day and the NFL combines, third-string back T.J. Yeldon offers a better overall option.

Yeldon, to me, is vastly underutilized. He’s bigger, faster, and a better pass receiver than Singletary or Moss.  Given the anemic nature of the Buffalo running game, perhaps Yeldon should see more game-day touches.

Let’s just say it:  The Bills’ defense is bad

Buffalo’s has yet to put together a complete defensive performance. In fact, other than the opening half against the Jets, little has gone right for the Buffalo on that side of the ball.

Sure, incumbent starters such as Tre White, Matt Milano, and Tremaine Edmunds have missed some time, but those absences do not explain the severe dropoff from last year to this year.

The Bills rank in the bottom 10 of the NFL in total yards allowed and are giving up 86 more yards per game than last season. They’re also not helping with the turnover battle.

Through six games, the Bills have recorded just two interceptions, and forced seven total turnovers. Worse than that is the third-down defense

Overall, Buffalo is 30th out of 32 teams in third-down defense, and it is worst in the NFL over the last three weeks allowing opponents to convert 60.5 percent of their third down opportunities.

If you’re thinking, “wow, the Bills can’t seem to make a big stop,” you’re absolutely right.

To start 2018, and obviously in rebuild mode, Buffalo allowed 78 total points in losses to the Ravens and Chargers. At that point, McDermott took over the defensive play-calling from coordinator Leslie Frazier. Going forward, largely, the Bills played stern defense finishing second overall in the NFL.

McDermott eventually ceded defensive play-calling back to defensive coordinator Frazier, and for nearly two years, Frazier has had the Buffalo defense humming.

 As consistently bad as the Buffalo defense has played, McDermott may want to temporarily return to calling the defense.

Defense isn’t playing physical – or smart

The Chiefs, not known at all as a physical running team, bulldozed the Buffalo front four creating huge running lanes for their running backs.

Give Kansas City some credit for its motion, play calls, and scheme, but the  Bills never did adjust.  Except for late-game situations where Buffalo was prepared for a KC run, the Buffalo front seven was confused and outmuscled.

We also saw some uncharacteristically dumb penalties from a usually heady defense. White was called for a late hit when he shoved a KC receiver out of bounds. No, it wasn’t a bang-bang play, either. White hit the Kansas City player at least three or four yards out of bounds.

On the same drive, Buffalo safety Jordan Poyer was flagged with an unnecessary roughness call after rag-dolling KC running back Clyde Edwards-Helaire, who was already out of bounds.

Paraphrasing McDermott in his post-game comments, he summed up that there is no room for that, and we’re more disciplined than that.

Oh, and an after-thought in Buffalo’s woes is the absence of a consistent pass rush. Like nearly every other defensive stat, Buffalo is in the bottom-half of the league in total sacks.

Likely the Bills are better than this, but the game film does not lie.

Special teams are getting better

Returner Andre Roberts popped a nice punt return Monday, kicker Tyler Bass made his longest field goal of the season connecting from 48 (although he missed badly from 52), and punter Corey Bojorquez is playing out of his mind.

Bojorquez has the NFL’s longest punt this season, and he’s averaging 50.8 yards per kick this season – third in the NFL. He’s also consistently flipping field position with more than half his punts ending up inside the opponent’s 20.

Virtually zero big plays from the receivers

The last two weeks, Buffalo has had little more than a possession- to medium-range passing game. John Brown had zero catches again – although he did draw a pass interference. Meanwhile, Stefon Diggs and Cole Beasley are helping move the chains with 8- to 12-yard plays but nothing much else.

And the fourth wideout, Gabriel Davis, is averaging only three targets a game. That stat seems almost criminal as he will catch virtually anything in his zip code.

The Chiefs’ defensive scheme was geared to stop the big play, but Allen is not taking many shots. Provided he doesn’t overthrow his target by 10 yards, good things have happened when Buffalo goes deep. That comes in in either a defensive penalty, or a nice completion.

And what about the tight ends?  Let’s just say, tight ends are not an integral part of a Buffalo offensive game plan.  Through six games, the four Buffalo tight ends have a combined 14 catches. 

Not a lot of good news coming out of Buffalo, but things are looking up. Buffalo clashes with the winless Jets this Sunay.

Follow the writer on Twitter @PatrickLNewell

Five things we learned from Buffalo’s week 3 win over the Rams


Buffalo coughed up a 25-point second-half lead to the Los Angeles Rams, but a clutch TD drive from quarterback Josh Allen gave the Bills a thrilling 35-32 win over the Rams Sunday at Bills Stadium.

Buffalo raised its unbeaten record to 3-0, and maintained a one-game lead over perennial AFC East champion New England. 

Next week, the Bills cross the country to face an improved Las Vegas Raiders club.  Here are five standout items from today:

Allen good, Allen bad (but mostly good).

After failing to throw for 300 yards in his first 27 starts, the third-year Bills quarterback now has three straight 300-yard passing games this season.

He threw for four touchdowns and ran for a fifth, and is among the NFL’s most productive quarterbacks through three weeks.

Yet, there were some blemishes that came with the win.  He had his first interception (questionable as it was), fumbled the ball away on a sack, and on that sack, was also whistled with an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty that led to a Rams score.

And on the winning drive, Allen set himself back 15 yards with that deadly quarterback facemask penalty. Yes, Allen, with ball in hand, grabbed and held the face mask of a Los Angeles pass rusher with his left hand.

Even in the most polished Buffalo wins, Allen has at least one or two head-scratching moments.

Running game picks up

Buffalo didn’t commit to the running game with same frequency as the Rams, but running back Devin Singletary – and backup T.J. Yeldon – rushing a combined 16 times for 89 yards. 

Singletary found room to run on numerous occasions, and this should build some confidence moving forward.

Defense lackluster for a second straight week

The Bills were missing Matt Milano and Tremaine Edmunds in the middle of the field last week, and Miami quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick took full advantage nearly leading his team to an upset victory.

Milano and Edmunds were back this week, but it made little difference as the Rams moved up and down the field at will throughout the second half.

Los Angeles mustered 488 total yards, and did not punt one time. Buffalo had no answers on defense the past two weeks, and this lineup – mostly intact from a year ago – is a far cry from that top-five defense.

Special teams solid

Kicker Tyler Bass made all his extra points, but he did do his job on kickoffs with five touchbacks in five kickoffs.  Over the last two weeks, Bass has surrendered just that lone kickoff return.

Punter Corey Bojorquez has done his job in this brief season. He averaged 58 yards on two kicks, including a career-best 72-yarder, and both punts were downed inside the Rams’ 20.

Lastly, returner Andre Roberts didn’t get much work, but he again showed his decisiveness averaging 36.5 yards on two returns. Roberts has the air of someone ready to bust one for a touchdown at any moment.

Bills injuries

Receiver John Brown, who came up big the first two weeks, had his first catch-free game as a Bills player. He suffered a calf injury in the opening half, and did not see action the rest of the way. Brown is a critical complement to opposite wideout Stefon Diggs, and Brown’s absence probably conspired against Diggs’ numbers today.

Also missing time was starting safety Micah Hyde, along with starting offensive lineman Dion Dawkins. Hyde and Dawkins are critical components to the Bills’ roster, and their injury status bears watching this coming week.

Extra points:  With starting tight end Dawson Knox out this week with a concussion, backups Tyler Kroft and Lee Smith responded with three combined TD receptions. …Rookie receiver Gabriel Davis made a case for more touches with four receptions for 81 yards. Oh, and perhaps you remember his go-ahead diving TD catch last week against the Dolphins. The Bills hit the mark selecting Davis as a fourth-round draft pick. …Tre White spent 2019 shutting down receivers and not allowing a TD pass to a receiver he was covering.  White, though, was easily beaten on a fourth-quarter TD reception by the Rams’ Cooper Cupp. …Former Buffalo Bills receiver, Robert Woods, continues to flourish in Los Angeles.  Woods gouged his former team 74 yards receiving and one score, and 30 yards rushing.

For more sports ramblings and commentary, follow the writer on Twitter @PatrickLNewell.

Norwich athletics coordinator pessimistic about resumption of extracurricular activities


The window for New York playing high school sports this fall is closing rapidly.

The New York State Public High School Athletic Association (NYSPHSAA) has issued several press releases, and recently published a tentative athletics plan if fall sports do not resume in September.

The surge of COVID-19 cases in late-winter canceled the conclusion of the 2020 state championships, and the spring sports season was completed wiped away as teachers and students sheltered in their homes, and completed required schoolwork virtually.

Earlier this month, we spoke to Norwich High School athletics coordinator, Rich Turnbull, regarding the state of sports – and all extracurricular activities.

Full disclosure, in my early years working for The Evening Sun, I covered Turnbull during his junior and season seasons playing varsity baseball for Edmeston.  I should also note, Turnbull, and his wife and children, live in Norwich next door to my parents.

“I guess I’ve become a little pessimistic,” Turnbull said in a phone interview earlier this month regarding the possibility of playing sports this fall.

Turnbull noted that part of New Yorik’s phase 4 reopening allowed for school teams to begin training, but that plan was scrapped when the NYSPHSAA ruled that no interscholastic teams could train, only travel teams.

“I lost a little bit of hope, because I thought the athletes would be allowed to train,” Turnbull said.

The guidance released by the state addresses the opening of schools, but clearly states, Turnbull said, no interscholastic activities at this time.

The moratorium on extracurricular activities will, presumably, extend to any academic clubs, music, arts, and theater.

“I think (the resumption of extracurricular activities) is a moving goal line,” Turnbull said. “If I was betting, I don’t see it happening.  I think every AD (athletics director) is frustrated, and we’re looking out for the safety of the kids. We just want some clear direction. It seems like everyone is canceling, and if we’re following the trend, I’m not very optimistic at all. How can you stay safe? If they’re not letting colleges play…basically, every college around us is canceling their seasons.”

Turnbull graduated from high school in the late 1990s, and still is not too far removed from competitive sports to remember the feeling he had playing sports.  He was asked how he would have felt if extracurricular activities were taken away

“As a kid, personally, I participated in everything,” Turnbull said. “I was in band, I was in choir, I played sports. I was in all sorts of stuff. If it was yanked, for me, I’d probably be disenfranchised, angry, and looking for things to do.”

Extracurricular activities, Turnbull said, were not just vehicles to keep a busy person occupied. They were also a means to develop as a person.

“I went to a small school, but I used the extracurricular activities as socialization and to meet with friends,” Turnbull said. “It would have really affected me mentally and socially. I wouldn’t have had that crutch to depend on – an outlet for activity.

Turnbull is also concerned that the absence of activities could bring an end to some sports as some school activities that are already hurting for numbers. 

“We have some kids that are just squeaking by, and without sports, they’ll seek other avenues to occupy their time,” Turnbull said.  “Some sports we have were already hurting for numbers. If we miss a whole season, will those sports be able to survive?”  Up-to-date guidance on New York scholastic sports is available online at http://www.nysphsaa.org/, and the most recent updates on the sports season are available on the COVID-19 Info link at http://www.nysphsaa.org/COVID-19-Info.

A Norwich treasure: Remembering Mr. Chirlin


Tornado logoThe Norwich community lost longtime teacher Don Chirlin on Saturday. Below are my recollections of Don over a 40-year period:

I learned yesterday that one of Norwich’s finest, Mr. Don Chirlin, passed away after a brief illness. Don celebrated his 84th birthday about four weeks ago, and until my mom emailed me last week, I was totally unaware he was sick. As recently as this past basketball season – before the virus shut things down – I knew Don was still attending Norwich games.
I have a connection to Don, his wife Sally, and children Christy and John dating back over 40 years.
My parents moved to our King Settlement road home in the late 1970s. We lived about a half-mile beyond the Chirlins’ home, but there were only three houses between our house and the Chirlins’ old farmhouse.
We were neighbors.
My presumption is that my parents knew the Chirlins to some degree. One of our first babysitters – and one of the last for that matter – was Christy.
The following year, I began my first year playing golf at Canasawacta Country Club. At some point, I connected with John, and for that summer and the next, John was a regular golf partner.
In retrospect, John was doing me a big favor. He was an older kid already in high school, and it was clear that he had some experience playing golf.
I was just a beginner.
During those two years, many times John and I got rides to the course from our parents. Sometimes it was my mom, but equally, Sally served as our chauffeur.
There were a couple of humorous experiences from those occasional rides – and if Sally reads this, she’ll know exactly what I am referencing. Sidenote: Sally reminded me of one specific occasion one of the last times I spoke to her.
We’ll leave that story off this page, but maybe I’ll tell that story in my memoirs.
During those two summers, I rode with John and Sally to and from the golf course countless times. But, I never actually met Don.
I saw the Chirlin patriarch all the time working on his property. There was at least a quarter-mile of open fields to the left and right of the Chirlin house. There was also an old barn and silo, likely the remnants of a one-time working farm.
Don was always outside working. Often, I saw him on his riding mower, and many other times I saw him driving around the property in a rusted-out, nearly-broken Jeep that had not been road-worthy in years.
Yet, I had never actually said a word to Don until my senior year in high school when I took his course: Problems in American Life. It was a social science elective, and Don lectured for an entire year on what he saw as the problems in American life.
Don was particularly passionate about the unit in which we discussed alcohol and drug addiction He confessed to his own addiction and recovery, and it was a rare instance where I saw a teacher exposing his own flaws and failures.
I didn’t appreciate that honesty while I was taking his class. In truth, it was a class credit I earned toward my high school graduation. Years later, when I got to know Don as a adult, I realized how thoughtful and complex Don was.
What I always found interesting about Don was his ability to turn it on and off. My impression of Don was that he was innately an introvert. His default setting is reserved and quiet. However, the moment the bell rang, and class started, he immediately sprung to life.
Anyone that heard Don speak publicly knew how passionate he was about the things he found important. He embarked on a professional career teaching social studies because of his deep interest and concern for history and social issues.
He was also deeply committed to his city and his alma mater. He served multiple stints on the Norwich City School Board, and was one of the most faithful and dedicated supporters of Norwich athletics.
Perhaps 10 years ago or more, Norwich started a sports hall of fame. Don was a staunch advocate of so many of his contemporaries’ inductions. He also spoke at several induction ceremonies, and he had few peers in his knowledge of Norwich sports history.
Many years after the start of the hall of fame, Don was inducted into the Norwich High School athletics Hall of Fame.
Because I didn’t come to know Don as a friend until he was already 60 years old, I had no idea he had any sports acumen. The Evening Sun published a biographical article of Don two years ago. Don was quoted in that article stating he was a good player on some really good teams.
Perhaps Don was a being a tad modest.
He was a two-way starter for Norwich’s last unbeaten and untied football team; he was the leading scorer on the 1952-’53 sectional basketball championship team; and he started on a baseball team that lost just one game.
A three-sport starter, the teams Chirlin played on went 40-4 overall his senior year. Describing himself as a good player and a really good team is like saying Scottie Pippen was a good player on the Chicago Bulls’ six NBA championship teams.
Pippen is in the NBA Hall of Fame, and Chirlin earned his NHS Hall of Fame induction.
Ten years removed from taking Don’s social studies class, I started the most important job of my life: sports editor at my hometown newspaper.
Over the course of 20 years, I talked with Don countless times, and he also wrote emails to me on many occasions. He and Sally were just incredibly supportive, positive, and informative influences during my career.
Second sidenote: I also had Sally as a teacher. She was my English and Comp II teacher when I was pursuing my two-year degree at Morrisville. I know my writing in this formal setting was garbage, but somehow, I finagled a B out of it.
I had great respect for Don and Sally who combined had at least 65-70 years of teaching experience. If my articles passed muster with the Chirlins, then I knew I was doing my job.
It’s been nearly five years since I moved from Norwich, and I only saw the Chirlins maybe two or three times in my visits home. One of my last communications with Don was an email he wrote to comment on a blog post. I always appreciated his insight and perspective.
Norwich lost one of the great ones on Saturday, and there are not many like him left.

Throw records out the window with this year’s Norwich team


Tornado logo

I’m home sick from work today – I guess whatever bug is coming through New Mexico, attached itself to me. But my fingers still work, and I had some additional thoughts about Norwich girls’ basketball’s season.

First, man, I wish I was there to cover this team in person.

Second, I covered the first eight seasons of Josh Bennett’s coaching tenure. He had some super talented teams, but there was always a Seton Catholic, a Sus Valley, or an Oneonta standing in the way.

As good as Norwich was, the opposition was simply exceptional. By my count, there were three times where Norwich lost competitive playoff games to the eventual state champion.

The disappointment of those losses laid the groundwork for the breakthrough of Norwich’s last two seasons.

A year ago, Norwich was just dominant from the opening tip of the first game, to the eventual blowout win in the Section IV championship.

This year, adversity struck on and off the court.

The Hess sisters, MacKenzie and Jordan, lost their father about a week before the season opener. Everyone that has ever competed in team sports knows that your teammates become your extended family. So, when members of your family are hurting, you hurt just as well.

If playing with heavy hearts wasn’t enough, two games into the season, Norwich lost perhaps its most important component, Halea Eaton, to injury.

Shortly before the start of the basketball season, Eaton inked a college basketball scholarship to LeMoyne. With Eaton guiding the Norwich offense, the Purple Tornado were the presumptive favorite to repeat as Section IV Class B champion.

Eaton is a do-everything type of a player who created opportunities for her teammates on offense, but also served as the hard-nosed first line of defense in Norwich’s full-court press.

If Norwich wanted to play at a 100 mile-per-hour pace, Eaton set the tone playing at 110 miles per hour.

We’ve all seen teams rally when a key player is lost. Perhaps the most obvious example I can point to is Loyola Marymount’s basketball team in 1990.

Loyola Marymount lost its best player, Hank Gathers, on the eve of the NCAA Tournament to a tragic heart ailment. Gathers, a consensus all-American, was irreplaceable as one the nation’s leading scorers and rebounders.

But, as prohibitive underdogs, Loyola Marymount willed itself to the NCAA west regional final achieving above and beyond expectations.

When you’re working with high level athletes – at the college or professional level – you’re replacing a high-level athlete with another high-level athlete.

That’s not as easy to do for a medium- to small-sized public high school. When you lose arguably your best player, the talent gap between that person and the replacement is substantial.

But, Norwich and Coach Bennett figured it out.

During the season, Norwich lost to Elmira, the Section IV AA champion, lost a close game to Class A champion Maine-Endwell, and lost twice to Oneonta, which came into the sectional tournament as the top seed in Class B.

The other two losses came to teams outside Section IV in tournament games designed to test the limits of the team. Those were losses to Saratoga Springs and Rome Free Academy. The former, Saratoga Springs, a school three times the size of Norwich, just lost in the Section 2, Class AA final to Shenendehowa.

While Rome Free Academy had a strong Section III season – also a AA-sized school – that ended in the playoffs.

Every Norwich loss was to above average to superior team. Other than Elmira and Saratoga Springs, Norwich was in every game deep into the fourth quarter.

Norwich went 14-6 during the regular season, which is certainly a fine record, but not one that portends of an upcoming championship.

As fans of our particular team, the overall record is the first detail we notice. It’s where we initiate some sort of rationalization; a starting point to forecast that team’s chances in the playoffs.

Coach Bennett, probably earlier in his career, placed some emphasis on the team’s record. He was a young coach, and he needed to produce a winning program.

A few years into his tenure, you started to see regular non-league dates against much larger schools. The wins and losses weren’t nearly as important as testing his players, and developing the team’s growth.

Undoubtedly, those six losses were the best lessons Norwich learned this season.

More than any year in his coaching career, Bennett needed “this” team to test its limits. In his post-game comments following Sunday’s sectional championship win over Newark Valley, Bennett said (following Eaton’s injury) that they had to reinvent and remake their team.

It was a 3 ½-month reinvention, and the fruits of that development have Norwich in the same position it was a year ago against the same team it lost to in the state playoffs: South Jefferson.

The most illustrative comparison we have to these two teams is last year’s playoff game. South Jefferson rallied in the fourth quarter to hand Norwich a 66-59 defeat. Norwich led a good chunk of that game, and South Jeff struggled to adjust to Norwich’s frenetic style of play, but settled in just enough to pull out the win.

As for this year, the two teams have one common opponent: Saratoga Springs. While Norwich lost by 21 (much of that disadvantage established in the first half), South Jefferson lost to that same team by 38 points.

Playing the comparison game isn’t usually a reliable tool for analysis. Especially at this point of the season when every team is playing its best basketball. What I did infer from the comparative box scores is one significant difference.

Bennett’s teams are the embodiment of himself. I’ve known Josh since he was a young teenager, and one thing you could count on to this day is his effort. You see it now in his coaching; he’s gives 100 percent from tip-off to final horn.

South Jefferson and Norwich were in similar situations entering the fourth quarter against Saratoga Springs. South Jeff was down 26, and Norwich trailed by 22.

In games like these, the benches are seeing most of the minutes on the floor. South Jefferson was outscored 14-2 in that last quarter. The outcome was conceded, and Saratoga Springs’ reserves played much better.

Conversely, with the game’s outcome no longer in doubt, Norwich won the fourth quarter against Saratoga Springs.

Maybe that doesn’t really mean that much. But what it means, from the outside, is that Norwich will compete hard for every minute of every quarter of every game.

That’s why I like Norwich’s chances in this weekend’s state playoff game as much as last year.

Highlights from Norwich’s win over Newark Valley are available at the following site.

The Norwich game highlights start at the 1:47 mark:   https://wbng.com/2020/03/08/class-a-and-b-crown-section-iv-champions/

5 things we learned from the Buffalo Bills’ playoff loss to Houston


Bills logoAs long as Deshaun Watson is taking the quarterback snaps, Houston is never out of a game.

Watson rallied the Texans from a 16-0 hole, and his elusiveness in the pocket led to a 34-yard completion to Taiwan Jones inside the Buffalo Bills 10.

From there, the Texans kicked the game-winning field goal in a 22-19 overtime win over the Bills on Wild-Card Saturday.

Watson did virtually nothing against the Bills’ defense until he capped the team’s first touchdown drive with a 20-yard touchdown run in the third quarter. Watson also threw a short TD pass in the fourth to Carlos Hyde that gave Houston its first lead of the game.

But it was Watson’s escape of an apparent sack at midfield that will define his playoff-winning performance.

Buffalo blitzers Siran Neal and Matt Milano each had their arms around Watson, who shrugged the two tacklers off on a scramble to the right. There, he found the little-used Jones on the right side near the first-down marker.

Jones, with his only touch of the game, reeled in the pass, made Bills safety Micah Hyde miss, and he rumbled down to the Buffalo 9.

The Bills, seeking their first playoff win since December 1995, will have to wait another season to break its 24-year playoff victory drought.

With the season now over for the Bills, what did we learn today? Here are five things:

The good and the bad Josh Allen

In four quarters plus 12 minutes of overtime, we saw both sides of the Allen coin. He was nearly flawless in the first half with an excellent quarterback scramble, a touchdown reception on a throwback from receiver John Brown, and he completed the passes he needed to make.

The second half was nearly the opposite. He lost a fumble early in the fourth that led to a Houston field goal, he took ill-timed sacks, and on a good quarterback run on the Bills’ drive for a tying field goal, inexplicably flipped a lateral over the head of teammate Dawson Knox while he was falling to the ground.

Yes, that’s a good sandlot play – if it worked – but the lateral nearly cost the Bills a penalty, and worse, the ball.

Playing it safe – too safe

As has been a theme all season for Buffalo, when it gets a lead, the offensive play-calling tends to lean towards the ultra-conservative.

Late in the first half, the Bills wasted valuable time as the clocked ticked down. With over a minute left in the half at the Houston 32, Allen completed a short pass to Cole Beasley. The clock continued to run, and fortunately, Buffalo completed a first-down pass to Devin Singletary for three yards to the Houston 23.

During those two plays, the Bills lost 47 valuable seconds, and inexplicably, after calling a timeout, with 30 seconds left ran Frank Gore for one yard. With the clock running, again, Allen had to spike the ball on second down to stop the clock. Then, Allen threw a low percentage pass to Duke Williams toward the right corner of the end zone.

That incompletion led to one of four Stephen Hauschka field goals.

Yes, the Bills put points on the board, but touchdowns will always trump field goals. The clock management and play-calling was not championship caliber, and the Bills’ mentality on offense – next season – should be redirected toward scoring touchdowns.

The Bills averaged 19 points a game on offense this season, and that will not get it done in today’s NFL.

Pass rushers had their best game

Forget about the missed sack in overtime – Watson did that to every team this season. The Bills had a season-high seven sacks, pressured Watson throughout the game, and forced the Texans to change their game plan.

If not for Watson’s superlative individual effort to evade Buffalo rushers, the Bills would be moving on to the divisional round of the playoffs instead of the Texans.

Jerry Hughes, the Bills’ most tenured player, had three sacks and three tackles for a loss in his best effort this season. Trent Murphy, who had two sacks last week, had a second straight two-sack game.

Where was Beasley? Knox?

It was a good move to elevate Duke Williams to the active roster, and he was the Bills’ most targeted receiver today with 10 targets.

As for free agent signee Cole Beasley, he’s a first down waiting to happen every time he is targeted, but his usage went silent for long stretches today.

In the slot, he is virtually uncoverable, and he caught a 10-yard pass for a first down with under 30 seconds to play leading to the Bills’ tying field goal.

He had one pass thrown his way in overtime – a low throw from Allen that went incomplete. Beasley is a weapon in the mold of the Patriots’ Julian Edelman, and he was vastly underused today.

Buffalo’s tight ends were also a non-factor. Dawson Knox had one catch in two targets, and veteran Lee Smith had one catch for eight yards. That was it for the Buffalo tight ends.

Knox, as we found out this season, is also a weapon and a mismatch for opposing defenses. But the tight ends were clearly not part of today’s offensive game plan.

Bills offense needs to get better

The Bills have put a championship caliber defense on the field the past two seasons. They finished in the top three both years, and it’s reasonable to expect the Bills will maintain a top-line defense in 2020.

Head coach Sean McDermott and general manager Brandon Beane fixed the defense fairly quick, but three years into the McDermott regime, the offense is still a work in progress.

In McDermott’s three seasons, the Bills’ offense has finished 29th, 30th, and 24th out of 32 NFL teams.

If Buffalo didn’t have a top-three NFL defense this season, it’s possible Buffalo could’ve finished with another six-win campaign.

Off Buffalo’s seven losses this year, six of those were one-score games. But in those losses, Buffalo scored two touchdowns or less. And, in all of its losses, it scored less than 20 points.

Some of this offensive inefficiency could be related to the first point: playing it too safe. It appears the offensive directive is to plays its cards close to the vest with Allen, and instead of making aggressive play calls on early downs inside the opponent’s 30, opts for low-risk, low-reward running plays.

The Patriots didn’t win six Super Bowls over the previous 18 years by playing it safe. To paraphrase Patriots coach Bill Belichick, “find an opponent’s weakness, and attack it without mercy.”

Follow the writer on Twitter @PatrickLNewell

Five things we learned from the Buffalo Bills’ loss to the Jets


Bills logoWith a playoff spot already in the bank, the Buffalo Bills played it safe Sunday in the season finale against the New York Jets.

With most Bills starters either taking a seat or only seeing cameo playing time, the surging Jets sent the Bills to their third loss in four games taking a 13-6 win at New Era Field.

The Jets, not the Patriots, Bills or Dolphins, had the best second half of the season in the AFC East winning six of their final eight games to finish with a 7-9 record.

Buffalo had an opportunity to reach 11 wins for the first time in 20 years, and the defense, despite using mostly reserves in the second half, played well enough for the Bills to win.

Buffalo’s offense, though, failed to eclipse 17 points for the ninth time in 16 games, and if not for a big drive late in the fourth that yielded a field goal, the Bills would have finished with under 300 yards of total offense a fourth straight game.

Anemic offense aside, here are five things we learned about the Bills

Williams shines again

Rookie receiver Duke Williams did drop a pass that cost Buffalo a likely first down, but the rookie receiver more than offset that with a six-catch, 108-yard performance. In the few opportunities he has had this year, Williams has delivered for the Bills.

He’s a big receiver with good hands, and he gives Buffalo a dimension at receiver that it doesn’t have, otherwise. Every game the rest of the way is “win or go home.” It would be a disservice to the Buffalo offense to deactivate Williams again, who is obviously a playmaker.

Yeldon over Gore?

You know what you’re going to get from Frank Gore. The durable 36-year-old Gore will run between the tackles, probably not fumble, and if there is any sort of daylight, he’s good for a three- or four-yard gain. Yeldon, though, offers more speed on the outside, he’s also a big back that can get the tough yards inside, and Yeldon is a far more dynamic pass catcher out of the backfield.

As much as we like Gore, Yeldon (like Williams), is much more of a playmaker for a Buffalo team that struggles to put points on the board.

Let’s hope Allen doesn’t get hurt

Matt Barkley showed some mettle in the fourth quarter driving Buffalo for a late field, but he limits Buffalo’s offense.

Barkley is strictly a pocket passer who usually makes quick decisions. But, he does not present nearly the arm strength, scrambling ability, and elusiveness of Allen.   Whenever he was hurried by the Jets’ pass rush, bad throws and inaccuracy cropped up. Barkley had two interceptions and one lost fumble, and that negative turnover ratio allowed the Jets to kick a clinching field goal.

Home field not an advantage; scoring insecurity

It’s a testament to Bills’ tough-mindedness and focus that they finished with a 6-2 record on the road, one of the better marks in the NFL.

However, at New Era Field, the Bills finished with same home record as a year ago when they finished 6-10 (a 4-4 home mark).

Three of those four losses were one-score games, and all but the Philadelphia loss were very winnable games. Again, a common theme was lack of scoring output.

One stat to note, and it’s quite revealing. The Bills scored more than 17 points seven times this season. In those seven games, the Bills were 7-0.

Bills punting game weak

Sorry Corey Bojorquez, but this will probably be your final season with the Bills. The Buffalo punter had two punts inside the 20 (he was punting at or near midfield on those two), but for the day, he averaged a mere 35.8 yards per punt.

Conditions were not the greatest today in Buffalo, but this is the professional level, and that quality of punting does not meet the NFL’s professional standard.

Next week: Buffalo will play at Houston next weekend in the AFC Wild Card round. Houston was locked into the fourth seed after Kansas City beat San Diego.

Follow the writer on Twitter @PatrickLNewell

Five things we learned from the Patriots’ division title victory over the Bills


Bills logoFor the 11th straight season, the Patriots will reign over the AFC East. Led by a vintage Tom Brady performance, the Patriots rallied past the Bills, 24-17, at Gillette Stadium on Saturday night.

Rex Burkhead, who had a big game last week against Cincinnati, followed that up with another clutch effort. He led the Patriots with 77 receiving yards, and scored on a 2-yard TD run with just over five minutes left for the winning points.

Buffalo entertained division title hopes if it was able to beat the Patriots, but the loss doesn’t hurt Buffalo’s playoff standing. The Bills are locked into the AFC’s 5th seed with tiebreaker advantages over the Steelers and Titans (the sixth- and seventh-seeded teams).

So, what did we learn from the Bills’ fifth loss of the season? Here are five things.

New England outcoached Buffalo today

Instead of outcoached, perhaps a better term is that the Bills were out-schemed today. More than any other game this season, the stingy Buffalo defense struggled to get off the field.

The Patriots moved the ball up and down the field most of the game, and finished with 414 total yards.

The Belichick-led Patriots struggled to move the ball in the previous meeting with Buffalo, but learned a few things from that hard-fought 16-10 win. They mixed in a power running game with crafty misdirection in the passing game.

There were few deep passes by Brady, but he consistently found wide-open receivers thanks to pre-play motion, play-fakes, and decoys.

It’s not something you would expect to work the next time around – Buffalo’s defensive staff has consistently shown its ability to adjust – but for a game, when the Patriots needed a spark, they got it done.

Ill-timed sacks taken by Allen

Bills quarterback Josh Allen has developed a reputation as a comeback kid, of sorts. He has five comeback wins this season, and has had Buffalo in position in its last two losses to tie the game on its final drive.

One theme, apparent in the losses to the Patriots and the Ravens two weeks ago – by the same 24-17 score – is Allen taking sacks in critical situations. Today, he held onto the ball on 3rd down giving up a sack. That put Buffalo in a desperate 4th-and-goal from the 15.

Allen has been criticized for his hero ball, which have led to some bonehead passes in his first two seasons. But that hero ball, many times, has also paid off with great improvisational plays.

We tend to forget all the times Allen has scrambled out of danger to make a great play.

The turnovers for Allen are way, way down since early in the year, but it almost seems like Allen has reined in the improvisational plays too much.

Given the enormity of the moment, on the 3rd-and-goal play, it would’ve been nice to see Allen scrap the called play quickly since it was obvious his first look wasn’t there, tuck it down, and get Buffalo into a more manageable fourth down.

Too many times this season Allen has held onto the ball too long on big third -down plays. One of the oldest truisms in football – on third down – is to not throw an interception, and do not take a sack. The latter has happened all too often for Allen in big moments.

Running game absent

Allen scrambled for over 40 yards, but aside from a couple good first-half runs by rookie Devin Singletary, the Bills were one-dimensional today.

The Bills’ generally conservative offensive approach is dependent on a good running game, and that running game was shut down by the Patriots in the second half.   The Patriots were the more physical team at the line of scrimmage today, and that hasn’t happened much this season for the Bills.

Buffalo finds the big play

The big plays for the Buffalo offense have come few and far between. Most Buffalo scoring drives this season were the culmination of well-executed possessions mixing good runs with short, high-percentage passes.

Late in the first half, Allen showed excellent touch on a 33-yard completion to Dawson Knox that led to a nifty TD pass from Allen to eligible lineman Dion Dawkins. (Dawkins caught a TD from Matt Barkley last year as well).

In the third quarter, Allen had a brilliant hookup with John Brown for a 53-yard TD connection. Brown beat all-pro Stephen Gilmore with a move to the outside, then turned to the middle of the field where he blew by safety Devin McCourty.

In the face of pressure, Allen dropped the ball in perfectly to Brown giving Buffalo a 17-13 lead. With a playoff game pending in two weeks, it’s nice to know Buffalo can execute a big play when it needs to.

Brady barely touched

You can count on one hand the number of times Brady was hit today on drop-backs. According to the game statistics, Brady was only hit four times, and the Bills registered zero sacks against the Patriots for the second time this season.

In recent weeks, the Bills’ rushers have shown the ability to get to the quarterback, but Brady had more than enough time today to pick out an open receiver.

Unlike the first meeting with the Bills when Brady failed to complete 50 percent of his passes, he hit 26 of 33 today for 271 yards. It was certainly the best individual passing performance of any quarterback to face the Bills this season, and much of that was due to superb pass protection.

Follow the writer on Twitter @PatrickLNewell

Buffalo Bills clinch playoff spot


Bills logo

The Buffalo Bills are headed to the postseason for the second time in three seasons.

The Bills’ defense picked off Pittsburgh quarterback Devlin “Duck” Hodges four times – the clincher an interception by Levi Wallace with under 10 seconds to play – as Buffalo held on for a 17-10 win over the Steelers at Heinz Field on Sunday night.

The Bills (10-4) also reached 10 wins for the first time in 20 years when they went 11-5 in 1999. That season, of course, ended with the Music City Miracle in a loss to the Tennessee Titans.

The Buffalo win sets up a showdown with division leader New England next Saturday afternoon, who hold a one-game lead over the Bills in the AFC East.

What did we learn from the Bills’ first Sunday night prime time appearance in 12 years? Here are five things.

Bills are road warriors

Three of Buffalo’s losses this season, surprisingly, have come at the friendly confines of New Era Field. But, that 6-1 road record Buffalo currently owns? That’s tied for the fewest road losses along with the Ravens, Chiefs, 49ers, Seahawks, and Saints.

Winning at Pittsburgh, before a raucous, loud, and boisterous fan base, is no easy feat for any NFL team, and the Bills owned the fourth quarter with a playoff spot on the line.

Just as a side note, the win over Pittsburgh, was the first in 20 years (that same 1999 11-win season).

Tre’Davious White is legit

Quarterbacks throwing White’s way do so at their own peril. White did give up a couple of catches tonight, but he also picked off Hodges two times. The second he took back 50 yards to set up a tying field goal from Devlin Hodges.

White has six interceptions on the season to share the NFL lead with Stephen Gilmore of New England, and probably locked up an all-pro nod with tonight’s performance.

Bills sloppy

Buffalo took some ill-timed penalties, including a big holding penalty with 1:40 left in the fourth, which allowed Pittsburgh one more chance at the tying touchdown.

On special teams, is there ever a time when Andre Roberts executes a decent punt return or kick return, and it isn’t called back due to penalty?

Josh Allen did throw an interception, although it did come off a tipped ball from receiver Cole Beasley. And Devin Singletary ran it well, but also had a case of fumble-itis. He fumbled twice, and lost it once on a third-quarter drive inside the Pittsburgh 30.

Jordan Phillips leading the sack crew

Phillips came over to Buffalo last year as a cast-off from the Miami Dolphins. He proved a capable plug-in defensive tackle a season ago to add to the Bills’ depth. But this season has proven a breakout campaign.

Phillips had two more sacks tonight giving him a team-high 9.5 on the season. That’s four more sacks than his combined career total over his first four seasons.

Tyler Kroft appears at the big time; Brown bounces back

On a third-and-nine at the Pittsburgh 14 and the score tied at 10-10, most would assume the Bills would play it conservative, and settle for a go-ahead short field goal.

Instead, the Bills split three receivers wide left, with veteran tight end Tyler Kroft on the right side. Instead of trying his tried-and-true receivers, Allen found a wide-open Kroft in the right corner of the end zone for a touchdown.

You couldn’t fault Pittsburgh for not closely guarding Kroft.

Kroft had just two catches over the previous four games, and had not caught a touchdown pass since the 2017 season with Cincinnati.

Allen didn’t look at his tight ends much tonight, but he found the right one at the right time.

Seeing John Brown take a more active role in the offense was also a welcomed sight.

Over the previous three weeks, Brown had eight total catches for 91 yards. Tonight, Brown had seven catches for 99 yards, and his 40-yard reception preceded the Bills’ winning touchdown. Brown is now in striking distance of a 1,000-yard season with 64 catches for 908 yards.

Follow the writer on Twitter @PatrickLNewell

Bills lose to red-hot Ravens


Bills logo

Hosting the red-hot Baltimore Ravens, the Buffalo Bills’ comeback attempt felt a touchdown short in a 24-17 loss to the Ravens Sunday afternoon at New Era Field.

It was the ninth straight win for Baltimore, who clinched an AFC playoff spot with the road victory.

Buffalo had an opportunity to reach 10 wins in a season for the first time since 1999, while also cementing a second AFC playoff spot in three seasons.

A road date next Sunday night at Pittsburgh looms for the Bills. Here are five things we learned from today’s game:

Buffalo is in the upper echelon of the NFL

During their nine-game winning streak, the Ravens have blown out last year’s Super Bowl teams – the Patriots and Rams – and beat an excellent 49ers team at the buzzer last weekend.

Few teams have hung with the Ravens for four quarters over the last two months, and Buffalo was in position to score a tying touchdown in the final minute.

Marcus Peters broke up a Josh Allen pass to John Brown on a fourth-down throw with just over a minute to play to wrap up the Baltimore win.

Baltimore had to work for this one, and in contrast to previous wins where the offense gained the spotlight, it took a supreme defensive effort to knock off the Bills.

Although it was Buffalo’s fourth loss of the season, its stock should not take a hit at all among NFL pundits.

Jackson can throw it

Other than a couple of nice first-down runs, the Bills held Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson in check with just 40 yards on 11 carries. But Jackson’s improvisational skills benefit his ability to throw the ball.

He made excellent decisions, bought time with his legs, and just narrowly missed some deep connections to his tight ends that were  off fingertips. The fact that his passing ability is rapidly catching up to his ability to run it could make him nearly indefensible in the near future.

Ravens’ pressure the difference

The Baltimore defense had six sacks of Buffalo quarterback Josh Allen, forced a fumble, and tacked on numerous other hard hits on the second-year quarterback.

Seldom did the Buffalo line give Allen the requisite time to find open receivers, and perhaps Allen was a bit shell-shocked as he often scrambled out of the pocket before he was in imminent danger of a sack.

The only other game where Allen was this rattled was the 16-10 loss to the Patriots. The Patriots also pressured Allen regularly, and picked him off three times.

In fact, you can point to the opponent’s pass-rushing effectiveness as a common thread in all four of Buffalo’s losses.

The Buffalo defense played well enough to win

If you told Buffalo fans before the game that the Ravens’ powerful running game would amass only 118 rushing yards (more than 80 below their average), and pick up only 3.6 yards per carry (nearly 2 yards below their season average), you would have some ecstatic fans.

Two of Baltimore’s touchdowns came with short fields – one after the Bills’ lone turnover, and the other after a poor punt.

Baltimore entered the game as the NFL’s highest scoring team, and second in total yards. Buffalo held the Ravens well below both numbers, but didn’t get the complementary play – today – from the offense.

Buffalo punting a glaring weakness

As mentioned earlier, Buffalo punter Corey Bojorquez’s poor punt in the second half led to Baltimore’s third and deciding touchdown.

Bojorquez has been near the bottom of the NFL all season in gross punting average, and after a 67-yard punt that went for a touchback on Buffalo’s first drive, he was extremely inconsistent.

Over his final six punts, he averaged just 38.8 yards, and if not for some fortuitous rolls, would’ve averaged in the low 30s.

Heading into this week, there were only two other full-time NFL punters averaging under 44 yards a punt aside from Bojorquez.

This is an area of weakness for Buffalo, and a position it will need to upgrade in the offseason – if not sooner.

Follow the writer on Twitter @PatrickLNewell